Property
-
August 11, 2025
Panel Says Public Health Order, Not COVID, Is An Occurrence
Governmental COVID-19 shutdown orders, and not the pandemic itself, are what constitute an "occurrence" under Life Time Fitness' commercial property policy with Zurich American Insurance Co., a Minnesota state appeals panel ruled Monday, specifically analyzing an "interruption by communicable disease" endorsement providing up to $1 million per occurrence.
-
August 08, 2025
BofA Must Face Trust Property Suit, Ga. Judge Says
A Georgia federal judge refused to let Bank of America escape a proposed class action accusing it of overcharging residential trusts for insurance, ruling in part that the named plaintiff can seek damages for his breach of trust claim against the bank.
-
August 08, 2025
Ga. Court Keeps Insurer's Shooting Coverage Dispute Alive
A Georgia federal judge refused to grant AMCO Insurance Co. an early win on most claims in its suit asserting it has no duty to defend an Atlanta apartment complex sued by a resident who was struck by bullets while sleeping.
-
August 07, 2025
Fire Victims See Positive Step In Calif.'s FAIR Plan ActionÂ
California regulators gave fire victims a boost last week when the state's insurance department launched a legal action seeking penalties against the state's last-resort insurer for its handling of smoke damage claims, but the market effects of the move are still not fully clear.Â
-
August 07, 2025
10th Circ. Water Loss Ruling Spotlights Competing Exclusions
The Tenth Circuit recently affirmed that a water damage exclusion applied to a Kansas office building's $1.75 million repair claim from a broken water pipe, providing insurance experts an unusual case for weighing two seemingly related exclusions against one another.
-
August 07, 2025
 Ill. Auto Rate Initiative Puts Pricing Accuracy In Spotlight
Illinois Secretary of State Alexi Giannoulias launched a new campaign aimed at reducing auto insurers' use of nondriving factors when setting rates on the grounds that these elements contribute to discriminatory rate-setting, but insurer and consumer advocates are split over the initiative's efficacy and potential cost increases.Â
-
August 07, 2025
Judge Says Flood Exclusion Sinks Storm Coverage Suit
A jewelry store's property insurer owes no coverage over claims for rainstorm damage, a Michigan federal court ruled Thursday, finding an exclusion barring coverage from water overflow due to floods was applicable.
-
August 07, 2025
Insurance Litigation Week In Review
The Archdiocese of New York demanded disclosure of reinsurance policies in a discovery-related appeal amid underlying sex abuse litigation, Zurich was accused of putting both its interests ahead of another insured's, a Georgia poultry producer sued for data breach coverage and an insurer sought to avoid covering racketeering claims.
-
August 07, 2025
Smoke Taint Evidence Complicates Recovery For Wineries
Recent widespread fires in and around California's wine-producing regions, which produce a vast majority of the nation's wine, have spurred concern from policyholders and public officials over how wineries can seek coverage for smoke tainting their products. Victor Jacobellis, an insurance recovery attorney at Merlin Law Group, spoke to Law360 about the implications of smoke taint as well as a Senate bill that could provide a baseline standard for measuring it.
-
August 07, 2025
Minn. Cyberattack Brings Cities' Cyber Policies Into Focus
A recent cyberattack against St. Paul, Minnesota, highlights the importance of cyber coverage for cities and counties, with the caveat that financial vitality, state and federal laws, and third parties retained for incident response can impact a municipality’s amount of coverage and the ways in which it can respond, Reed Smith LLP partner J. Andrew Moss told Law360.
-
August 07, 2025
Insurer Says Conviction Bars Coverage For Police Injury Suit
An insurer has no duty to defend or indemnify a man facing a civil claim of negligently blinding a Los Angeles police officer with a laser, it told a California federal court, saying the man's criminal conviction for assault means his conduct was intentional and therefore not covered.
-
August 06, 2025
Insurer Can't Escape La. Church's $5M Hurricane Ida Suit
An insurer can't escape a Louisiana church's suit seeking nearly $5 million in coverage for claimed Hurricane Ida damage, a federal court ruled Wednesday, rejecting the insurer's contention that the church breached the policy's cooperation requirement and failed to provide timely proof of loss.
-
August 06, 2025
COST Asks Mich. Justices To OK Nationwide's Unitary Tax Win
The Council on State Taxation backed entities of Nationwide in the Michigan Supreme Court on Wednesday, saying the justices should affirm an appellate court's decision that said the insurance company's affiliates are entitled to file their taxes as a combined group of businesses.
-
August 06, 2025
Ceramics Co. Seeks Biz Interruption Coverage Over Hurricane
A ceramics and home goods retailer accused a Travelers unit of violating North Carolina's unfair claims settlement practices and deceptive trade practices laws, telling a federal court the insurer deliberately misrepresented statements from its chief financial officer to support its denial of the retailer's Hurricane Helene claim.
-
August 05, 2025
Homeowners Policy Doesn't Cover Shooting, 6th Circ. Says
State Farm has no duty to defend or indemnify a man facing wrongful death claims after he unintentionally shot and killed a woman in a domestic dispute, the Sixth Circuit affirmed Tuesday, finding that his intentional gunshots still created a foreseeable risk of harm and thus weren't an insurable accident.
-
August 05, 2025
Insurer Must Turn Over Adjuster Docs In Hotel's Fire Loss Suit
A hotel owner's insurer must turn over certain documents relating to the disciplinary history, compensation and qualifications of certain claims adjusters, an Idaho federal court ruled after the owner accused the insurer of intentionally delaying the resolution of its fire loss claim.
-
August 05, 2025
Property Co. Sues Zurich Over Music Video Shooting Defense
Zurich failed to adequately defend claims over a shooting that occurred during the filming of a music video for rapper Lil Baby, an Atlanta property owner told a Georgia federal court, saying it's entitled to retain independent counsel at the insurer's expense due to an ongoing conflict of interest.
-
August 05, 2025
States Win Ruling To Shield FEMA Disaster Prevention Funds
A Massachusetts federal judge on Tuesday temporarily barred the Trump administration from redirecting more than $4 billion in funds allocated by Congress for natural disaster mitigation efforts toward other Federal Emergency Management Agency programs.
-
August 04, 2025
Title Insurer Faces Partial Loss In $26M Loan Dispute
A lender's title insurer breached its duty to defend mechanic's lien lawsuits from subcontractors after a senior living community owner defaulted on its nearly $26 million construction loan, a Colorado federal court ruled, adding that the insurer had to indemnify certain amounts of the general contractor's lien claim, too.
-
August 04, 2025
Lowenstein Sandler Hires New Insurance Recovery Partner
Lowenstein Sandler LLP has added a new partner to its insurance recovery group who has a wide breadth of experience in not only representing corporate policyholders, but also in advising clients in general commercial cases, the firm announced Monday.
-
August 01, 2025
Most Of Property Co.'s Hailstorm Insurance Fight Tossed
A property investment company can raise nearly none of its claims against its insurer for hailstorm damage from 2019 and 2023, a North Carolina federal court ruled, finding that because claims concerning the 2019 storm are time-barred, those corresponding documents can't support much of the 2023 claims.
-
July 31, 2025
Top Property Insurance Decisions So Far In 2025
A U.K. decision over coverage for Russian-seized aircraft and a Second Circuit ruling in favor of international insurers seeking to arbitrate hurricane damage claims are among some of the biggest decisions in the property insurance space so far in 2025.
-
July 31, 2025
CGL Cases To Watch In The Second Half Of 2025
Federal and state courts continue to weigh litigation involving public nuisance, long-tail environmental and sexual abuse claims. Here, Law360 breaks down some of the blockbuster commercial general liability insurance cases to follow in the second half of the year.
-
July 31, 2025
10th Circ. Says Water Exclusion Bars Co.'s $1.75M Loss
A Kansas office building's property insurer has no duty to provide coverage for roughly $1.75 million in repairs over a broken water pipe, the Tenth Circuit ruled, rejecting the building owner's argument that an exception in one exclusion conflicted with a separate exclusion for water damage.
-
July 31, 2025
Insurer Avoids Businesses' COVID-19 Coverage Claims
A property insurer for numerous restaurants, bars and other small businesses owes no coverage for their consolidated business interruption claims related to the COVID-19 pandemic, an Illinois federal court ruled, looking to the laws of Illinois, Michigan, Wisconsin, Indiana, Iowa, Minnesota and Tennessee.
Expert Analysis
-
State Farm Rate Hike Portends Intensifying Insurance Crisis
The California Department of Insurance's unprecedented emergency approval of a 17% rate increase for State Farm General Insurance, the first interim rate relief granted before completing full actuarial justification, represents a regulatory watershed and establishes precedent that could fundamentally reshape insurers' response to climate-driven market instability, says Daniel Veroff at Merlin Law Group.
-
3 Corporate Deposition Prep Tips To Counter 'Reptile' Tactics
With plaintiffs counsel’s rising use of reptile strategies that seek to activate jurors' survival instincts, corporate deponents face an increased risk of being lulled into providing testimony that undercuts a key defense or sets up the plaintiff's case strategy at trial, making it important to consider factors like cross-examination and timing, say attorneys at Dentons.
-
Statistics Tools Chart A Path For AI Use In Expert Testimony
To avoid the fate of numerous expert witnesses whose testimony was recently deemed inadmissible by courts, experts relying on artificial intelligence and machine learning should learn from statistical tools’ road to judicial acceptance, say directors at Secretariat.
-
Calif. Bar Exam Fiasco Shows Why Attys Must Disclose AI Use
The recent revelation that a handful of questions from the controversial California bar exam administered in February were drafted using generative artificial intelligence demonstrates the continued importance of disclosure for attorneys who use AI tools, say attorneys at Troutman.
-
In 2nd Place, Va. 'Rocket Docket' Remains Old Reliable
The U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia was again one of the fastest civil trial courts in the nation last year, and an interview with the court’s newest judge provides insights into why it continues to soar, says Robert Tata at Hunton.
-
Measuring The Impact Of Attorney Gender On Trial Outcomes
Preliminary findings from our recent study on how attorney gender might affect case outcomes support the conclusion that there is little in the way of a clear, universal bias against attorneys of a given gender, say Jill Leibold, Olivia Goodman and Alexa Hiley at IMS Legal Strategies.
-
2nd Circ. Arb. Ruling May Give Foreign Insurers An Edge
The Second Circuit's decision this month in Lloyds of London v. 3131 Veterans Blvd that international arbitration agreements take primacy over state anti-arbitration insurance laws opens a division between domestic and foreign insurers that could affect the surplus lines market, says attorney Rosanne Felicello.
-
Oft-Forgotten Evidence Rule Can Be Powerful Trial Tool
Rule 608 may be one of the most overlooked provisions in the Federal Rules of Evidence, but as a transformative tool that allows attorneys to attack a witness's character for truthfulness through opinion or reputation testimony, its potential to reshape a case cannot be overstated, says Marian Braccia at Temple University Beasley School of Law.
-
30 Years Later: 2nd Circ.'s Road To Arbitral Preemption
The Second Circuit's recent decision in Lloyds of London v. 3131 Veterans Blvd. overturns its own 1995 precedent and squares its position with decades of circuit court jurisprudence holding that international arbitration agreements must take primacy over state anti-arbitration insurance laws, say attorneys at Linklaters.
-
What Disparate Impact Order Means For Insurers' AI Use
A recent executive order seeking to bar disparate impact theory conveys a meaningful policy shift, but does not alter the legal status of federal antidiscrimination law or enforceability of state laws, such as those holding insurers accountable for using artificial intelligence in a nondiscriminatory matter, say attorneys at Eversheds Sutherland.
-
4 Ways To Leverage A Jury's Underdog Perceptions
Counsel should consider how common factors that speak to their client's size, power, past challenges and alignment with jurors can be presented to try and paint their client as a sympathetic underdog, says Ken Broda-Bahm at Persuasion Strategies.
-
Why Hiring Former Jurors As Consultants Can Be Risky
The defense team's decision to hire former juror Victoria George in the high-profile retrial of Karen Read shines a spotlight on this controversial strategy, which raises important legal, ethical and tactical questions despite not being explicitly prohibited, says Nikoleta Despodova at ND Litigation.
-
Calif. Smoke Claim Ruling Gives Insurers Support On Denials
Far from being an outlier among ash, soot and smoke coverage cases, a California appellate court's recent opinion in Gharibian v. Wawanesa General Insurance reinforces the principle that policyholders must establish entitlement to coverage as a threshold matter, while supporting denials of coverage for meritless claims, says Kyle Espinola at Zelle.