An expectant mother and two immigrant advocacy organizations hit the Donald Trump administration with a midnight lawsuit in Massachusetts federal court in a bid to halt the president's executive order ending birthright citizenship in the United States.
The , brought by an unnamed woman whose baby is due in March along with La Colaborativa and the Brazilian Worker Center, argued that the 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution is clear that all people born in the country are citizens. The complaint said the president does not have the power to end the 157-year-old legal protection.
"This unprecedented attempt to strip citizenship from millions of Americans with the stroke of a pen is flagrantly illegal," the complaint states. "It is settled beyond all doubt that the president simply does not have the power to unilaterally revoke a person's birthright citizenship."
The suit followed similar litigation filed by the American Civil Liberties Union, which also challenged the constitutionality of the birthright citizenship executive order in New Hampshire federal court.
The Massachusetts complaint blasted the day-one executive order as "an unconstitutional abuse of power" that seeks to punish a group of people based on the immigration status of their parents. While the plaintiff mother has temporary protected status, according to the suit, the baby's father is neither a citizen nor a lawful permanent resident.
The complaint also argues that the executive order fails under the Fifth Amendment guarantee of due process.
"The EO treats the targeted citizens as a subordinate caste of native-born Americans, entitled to fewer rights, benefits, and entitlements than other Americans due to their parents' alienage," the suit states.
Signed shortly after Trump took office Monday, Trump's order is called "Protecting the Meaning and Value of American Citizenship" and states that the administration will not recognize automatic citizenship for any children born in the U.S. to immigrant parents who are in the country illegally.
The order, which constitutional experts have said faces steep legal hurdles, impacts children in cases where neither parent is a U.S. citizen. It makes good on a promise that originated during Trump's first administration, though it was never carried out during his first four years in the White House.
In addition to asking a federal court to block the order, Lawyers for Civil Rights, which filed the complaint, said it sought to highlight the "dire consequences" of the administration's policy.
"It would de-Americanize children and, as a result, deny them precious rights, legal protections, and the benefits that come with them, like access to critical documents such as passports and Social Security numbers," LCR said. "Affected children would be stripped of their national identity, stigmatized by their government as a class of 'lesser' Americans, and forced to live with the uncertainty and fear that comes with the possibility of deportation from their native land."
The complaint quoted the U.S. Supreme Court's 1958 ruling in , which held that revoking citizenship as punishment for a crime is unconstitutional, amounts to "the total destruction of the individual's status in organized society," and "is a form of punishment more primitive than torture."
"This executive order is a brutal and unconstitutional attempt to redefine what it means to be an American," LCR executive director Iván Espinoza-Madrigal said in a statement. "The Constitution is clear: birthplace, not parentage, determines citizenship in this country. This lawsuit is about ensuring that the fundamental rights guaranteed by our Constitution are upheld."
A White House representative did not immediately respond to a request for comment Tuesday.
The plaintiffs are represented by Lawyers for Civil Rights.
Counsel information for the government was not immediately available.
The case is O. Doe et al. v. Donald J. Trump et al., case number 1:25-cv-10133, in the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts.
--Editing by Daniel King.
							
						
					Try our Advanced Search for more refined results
Law360
|The Practice of Law
							
								Access to Justice
							
							
								Aerospace & Defense
							
							
								Appellate
							
							
								Asset Management
							
							
								Banking
							
							
								Bankruptcy
							
							
								Benefits
							
							
								California
							
							
								Cannabis
							
							
								Capital Markets
							
							
								Class Action
							
							
								Colorado
							
							
								Commercial Contracts
							
							
								Competition
							
							
								Compliance
							
							
								Connecticut
							
							
								Construction
							
							
								Consumer Protection
							
							
								Corporate
							
							
								Criminal Practice
							
							
								Cybersecurity & Privacy
							
							
								Delaware
							
							
								Employment
							
					
					
							Energy
							Environmental
							Fintech
							Florida
							Food & Beverage
							Georgia
							Government Contracts
							Health
							Hospitality
							Illinois
							Immigration
							Insurance
							sa国际传媒
							International Arbitration
							International Trade
							Legal Ethics
							Legal Industry
							Life Sciences
							Massachusetts
							Media & Entertainment
							Mergers & Acquisitions
							Michigan
							Native American
					
					
		Law360 Pulse
|Business of Law
Law360 Authority
|Deep News & Analysis
Healthcare Authority
Deals & Corporate Governance Digital Health & Technology Other Policy & ComplianceGlobal
- Law360
- Law360 Pulse
- Law360 Employment Authority
- Law360 Tax Authority
- Law360 Insurance Authority
- Law360 Real Estate Authority
- Law360 Healthcare Authority
- Law360 Bankruptcy Authority
- Products
 
- Law360 In-Depth
- Law360 Podcasts
- Rankings
- Leaderboard Analytics
- Regional Powerhouses
- Law360's MVPs
- Women in Law Report
- Law360 400
- Diversity Snapshot
- Practice Groups of the Year
- Rising Stars
- Titans of the Plaintiffs Bar
- Sections
- Adv. Search & Platform Tools
- About all sections
- Browse all sections
- Banking
- Bankruptcy
- Class Action
- Competition
- Employment
- Energy
- Expert Analysis
- Insurance
- sa国际传媒
- Product Liability
- Securities
- Beta Tools
- Track docs
- Track attorneys
- Track judges
Are you on track to meet your billable-hour target this year?
						Click here to take the Law360 survey
					
                    This article has been saved to your Briefcase
                    This article has been added to your Saved Articles
				
				Immigrant Orgs Sue Trump Over Birthright Citizenship Order
By Chris Villani | January 21, 2025, 10:08 AM EST · Listen to article